Chapter Text
"Are you sure you're okay to be alone with her, Judgy?" Damon asks as he leads Bonnie down to the Salvatore basement/dungeon. "I mean, you kinda lost it and almost killed her."
"I'll be fine," Bonnie replies. "I meant it when I told you and Stefan to leave the house, though. Elena clearly isn't going to listen to you and you two hovering around isn't going to help anything."
"Fine," Damon says reluctantly. "But if anything goes wrong..."
"Bye, Damon."
The vampire in question leaves.
"Come to pay me a visit for old times' sake?" Elena asks with a wry grin. "Or are you finally miserable enough to let me end your sad existence?"
Bonnie does her best to school her emotions. Instead, she crouches down in front of Elena so that she's eye-level with her.
"I understand how much losing Jeremy hurts--"
"It doesn't. That's the beauty of not having to feel," Elena replies condescendingly, rolling her eyes.
"I don't believe that, though. I think you can feel, but you just won't let yourself," Bonnie replies. "You're afraid to. Because you know that once you do you have to answer for everything you've done these past few weeks, you'd have to confront everything you just lost. Instead, you choose to take the easy way out."
"You know what I think?" Elena asks, examining her fingers nails uninterestedly. "I think you're secretly in love with me."
Bonnie sputters a bit, not sure how to reply to that.
"In fact, I'm pretty sure the only reason you were ever with Jeremy was because he was the closest you could get to having me."
"You're insane," Bonnie replies.
"Well, of course I am. That's part of the fun. It doesn't make me wrong, though." She leans in closer to Bonnie, her face close enough that the witch could feel her warm breath on it. "Don't tell me you never thought of it," Elena murmurs seductively. "What it would be like to kiss me, to grope my breasts, eat my pretty little pussy."
Bonnie could feel all the blood rush to her head and she can't quite wrap her mind around the strange turn this has all taken.
"C'mon, you know you wanna try it at least once."
And then Elena closes the distance between them, firmly sealing her mouth to Bonnie's. Bonnie lets out a small squeal of protest and attempts to pull away at first, but Elena quickly brings a hand to the back of the witch's head, holding her in place and forcing her tongue into her mouth.
"What happened to wanting to kill me?" Bonnie asks when Elena pulls away.
"Seducing you is so much more fun," Elena whispers back, her lips brushing against Bonnie's with every word. "You're always such a good girl, so why don't you be my good girl? Or, I suppose in this case, bad girl."
Despite herself, Bonnie could feel an ache starting between her legs.
"I can smell you getting wet."
And that's when Bonnie knows she's doomed.
Elena wastes no time in divesting both of them of their clothes.
Elena fondles Bonnie's breasts for a bit, pinching the nipples hard enough to straddle that delicate line between pleasure and pain. Then, Elena stands up and moves until her back is against the wall, spreading her legs wide and giving Bonnie a clear views of the treasure between her legs.
"Everybody else seems to find my twat so irresistible, so why don't you have a taste and find out for yourself why that is?"
Before Bonnie even really considers what she's doing, she's kneeling in between Elena's legs. She gives the slit a tentative lick, letting the taste settle before following it up with more substantial licks.
At first, she begins with long licks along the slit. She then moves to swab at Elena's swollen clit before sucking at it a bit. Then, she moves to Elena's dripping entrance and begins dipping her tongue in the hole.
"If I didn't know any better, I would think you've done this before," Elena hisses in pleasure, clutching at her own breasts.
The more Bonnie ate Elena's pussy, the more she could feel herself getting turned on. The witch slips a hand down towards her own pussy, intending to alleviate her own ache down there.
"Don't you dare, you little slut," Elena says, tugging on Bonnie's hair. "Your focus is on me and my pleasure right now. If you want something to do with your hands, then finger me."
Bonnie didn't think it was possible, but that turns her on more and she whimpers into Elena's pussy before she slips one finger and then two into the cushiony channel while she suckles at the vampire's clit.
"Ah, yeah, just like that," Elena groans, grinding against Bonnie's face. "Curl your fingers a little bit and move them fast."
After a few moments, Elena comes with a loud groan and she pushes Bonnie even further in to her pussy. When she comes down from her climax, Bonnie tries to pull away, but Elena doesn't allow her to.
"I'm not quite finished yet," Elena tells her, using her grip on the witch's hair to guide her back to her twat.
Bonnie lets out a small groan, but begins finger Elena's pussy again while eating her out.
"Who knew you could be such a good pussy licker?" Elena asks. "Then again, you've always been so eager to please. Maybe I'll keep you around just for this. My own little personal pussy pleaser. I'd have you eat me out any time I wanted you to. And you'd do exactly what I say because you've never known how to say no to me."
The throbbing between in Bonnie's pussy starts to become so insistent that Bonnie wonders if she might actually burst and have an orgasm without even touching herself.
After several more orgasms via Bonnie's mouth and fingers, Elena finally let's the witch pull away. She grins when she sees what a mess she's made on Bonnie's face.
Before Bonnie realizes what's happening, Elena has her on her back and is pulling her legs apart.
"I suppose you've earned this," Elena says with a grin and a small wink at Bonnie.
She slides two fingers into Bonnie and quickly curls them up before fiddling the witch's clit with her thumb. Elena soon picks up the pace, almost using her vampire speed, and while it feels so good, Bonnie's sure that it'll make her feel a bit raw and sore afterwards.
Bonnie orgasms with a shout and Elena doesn't stop until Bonnie falls over the edge once more. She pulls her fingers out of the witch's twat and sucks one of her sticky fingers into her mouth.
"Hmmm," Elena says as she sucks Bonnie's essence off her fingers. "You don't taste too bad."
Bonnie can't help but blush.
"Why don't you have a taste?" Elena asks, placing the other finger that was covered in Bonnie's cum against the witch's full lips.
Bonnie opens her mouth to protest, but Elena takes the opportunity to slide the finger in, forcing Bonnie to taste herself.
"Always such a good girl," Elena says with a saccharine smile.
Bonnie moans despite herself.
"Y'know," Elena says conversationally, as she slides her fingers back into Bonnie's pussy and curls them upwards. "I think things could get quite interesting with us. Me without my humanity, you taking your little walk on the dark side with your Expression magic. Just think of all the fun we can have together this way."