Work Text:
The streets of Valentine stretched out before you, painted in the muted hues of everyday chaos. The usual scenes played out as if on a loop: women coaxing drunken men from the saloon to the hotel under the guise of affection, only to rob them blind; men bickering loudly outside shops, fists clenched and tempers fraying; and horses ambling through the thick, muddy road, their hooves splashing against the mire. Nothing about the scene felt unusual—at least, not until you heard the creak of the sheriff’s office door swinging open behind you.
Your gaze shifted instinctively toward the sound, drawn to the figure stepping out. He was a large man, his presence commanding in a way that made the street seem quieter for a moment. The fabric of his shirt strained against the hard lines of his biceps as he studied a wanted poster in his hands, the late afternoon sun catching the sharp angles of his face.
“Arthur Morgan,” you said, your voice firm but laced with curiosity. His head tilted slightly at the sound, his rugged features shadowed in a way that made it hard to tell what he was thinking. With a practiced motion, he folded the poster and tucked it into his satchel before fixing his sharp eyes on you.
“Do I know you, miss?” he asked, his tone level but not unkind. It wasn’t the voice of a man trying to intimidate—it was the voice of someone cautious, someone who knew better than to let his guard down.
“No, sir,” you replied with a hint of a smile, taking a step closer. “But I know you. Pretty famous for starting bar fights, ain’t you?” Your words came out playful, a gentle tease meant to test the waters.
You watched his expression carefully, noting how the corner of his mouth twitched almost imperceptibly as if deciding whether to smile or scowl. You reached down, fingers brushing against the cold metal of the handcuffs clipped to your belt. With a sly smile, you slipped them free, letting the cuffs dangle from your hand. Slowly, you began to twirl them around your index finger, the metal glinting in the sunlight as they spun.
“I oughta arrest you,” you teased, your tone light but carrying a hint of mischief. “Causin’ so much disturbance, the way you do.”
Your gaze stayed fixed on his, testing the waters again, curious to see how far you could push him. The corners of his mouth twitched, that same unreadable expression lingering as he shifted his weight slightly, his broad frame casting a shadow over the muddy street.
He grasped the saddle horn with practiced ease, hauling himself up onto the horse in one fluid motion. Even astride the animal, his eyes never wavered from yours, steady and sharp, as though he were sizing you up.
“You’re the sheriff’s girl, ain’t you?” he drawled, his voice low and rough, tinged with amusement. His horse took a few slow steps forward, closing the distance between you. The movement brought him closer, and as he leaned ever so slightly in the saddle, his broad frame seemed to tower over you, casting a long shadow.
The faint scent of whiskey and cigarettes clung to him, the kind of rugged aroma that fit him too well. His breath fanned your face as his lips quirked into a smirk, his fingers adjusting the brim of his hat with a casual confidence.
“I reckon I’m in the clear for now,” he continued, his tone teasing but edged with a hint of cockiness, “seein’ as I’m workin’ for your pa.” His chuckle rumbled low in his chest, warm and deep, the sound lingering in the charged air between you.
He noticed the way your body stiffened at his words, a flicker of something—defiance, irritation, or maybe a mix of both—crossing your face. His response was a low, gravelly laugh, the kind that made the hair on the back of your neck stand on end.
“I’ll see you around,” he said, his voice softening just enough to sound almost genuine. That smirk lingered on his lips as he looked down at you, then with a sharp click of his heels against his horse’s sides, he spurred the animal forward.
You stood there, breath hitching in your throat, watching as he began to pull away. Something inside you twisted—a spark of impulsive recklessness igniting before you had time to think it through.
With a sharp inhale, you turned on your heel and reached for your own horse, adrenaline surging through you. In one swift motion, you hauled yourself into the saddle, gripping the reins tightly as the animal shifted beneath you. Without hesitation, you urged your horse forward, its hooves pounding against the muddy ground as you took off after him.
You pressed your back against the rough bark of a tree, peeking out just enough to catch sight of him. Arthur stood over his bounty, looming like a storm cloud, his presence as steady as the rifle slung across his back. The man he was after, a wiry fellow with a sharp tongue, was pleading desperately now, his words teetering between panicked bargains and bold threats.
Your fingers rested lightly on the grip of your revolver, your body tense as you watched the exchange. Every fiber of you was ready to step in if things took a turn, though something told you Arthur had everything under control.
“I don’t have the time of day for this, friend,” Arthur said, his voice calm but carrying an edge sharp enough to cut through the man’s bluster.
You stayed hidden, your eyes narrowing as the argument played out before you. The tension in the air thickened, and you could feel your muscles tighten, ready for anything. Suddenly, the man’s hand shot to his gun, his fingers twitching as he gripped it tightly. The sharp crack of a bullet cut through the air, and before you could react, you felt a searing pain tear through your thigh.
The bullet grazed you, ripping through the fabric of your jeans and drawing blood, the sting of it sharp and sudden. You winced, your breath catching in your throat as you instinctively gripped the bark of the log, steadying yourself against the shock.
Their argument ended as swiftly as it began—Arthur’s patience clearly running thin. With one clean, practiced motion, he silenced the man with a punch, the bounty crumpling like a sack of grain at his feet.
He crouched, pulling rope from his satchel, and hog-tied the man with an efficiency that almost impressed you. Throwing the bounty over his shoulder as though he weighed no more than a sack of flour, Arthur straightened, dusting his hands off.
“That required no effort, huh?” you called out, stepping into view, your voice light with amusement but your stance steady. You couldn’t help but grin as his gaze flicked toward you, a mixture of surprise and bemusement flashing across his face.
His eyes widened briefly, the surprise flickering across his face before it settled into a smirk. Amusement danced in his gaze as he hefted the unconscious man and tossed him onto the back of his horse with practiced ease, securing him tightly before turning his attention back to you.
“Well, I’ll be,” he drawled, his voice dripping with playful charm. “Didn’t know you were stalkin’ me. If I’d known a lady was watchin, I might’ve behaved a little more gentlemanly.”
His smile widened as he spoke, his tone teasing but not without a hint of sincerity. There was something disarming about the way he carried himself, as if he found humor in the situation but didn’t entirely mind your presence.
You took a step closer, your fingers slipping away from the grip of your revolver as the tension in your shoulders eased. With a quick, absent-minded motion, you run your fingers through your hair, pushing strands away from your face.
His gaze never left yours, steady and unwavering, the faintest trace of curiosity flickering in his expression. As you drew nearer, you noticed his hand flexing, his knuckles reddened and sore from the punch he’d thrown. He massaged them absently, the motion deliberate and unhurried, as if he had all the time in the world to size you up.
He took another step closer, his towering frame blocking out the sun as he loomed over you, the air between you thick with unspoken words. His eyes were steady, probing, almost daring you to respond.
He crouched down, his hands resting on his knees, bringing his face level with yours. His gaze was intense, but there was something almost tender beneath it as he studied you. His eyes swept over your figure, and then lingered on the wound on your thigh.
"I’m no doctor," he muttered, his voice low and laced with concern, "but let me take a look at that for ya. Your pa would have my hide if he knew you got hurt because of me." There was a sense of responsibility in his tone, an unspoken weight in the way he spoke of your injury. His large hands hovered near your thigh, a mix of hesitation and care in his actions, as if he were trying to decide whether to touch you or wait for you to make the next move.
He stood abruptly, his hands firm but gentle as he grasped you by the waist, lifting you with ease and settling you down onto a nearby log. He crouched in front of you, his eyes never leaving yours as his thumb brushed over the slit the bullet had left on your thigh, tugging at the wound carefully.
“I’m fine, Arthur. Really,” you managed, feeling a rush of shyness settle over you, but the wince that followed betrayed your words.
Arthur let out a low chuckle, his gaze softening as he took in your discomfort. “Let me take care of you,” he murmured, his voice both soothing and certain.
He licked his thumb and gently wiped away some of the blood that had already begun to stain your jeans. With practiced motions, he reached into his satchel, pulling out his black bandana and a bottle of whiskey. His fingers worked quickly, grasping the rim of the bottle and tilting it upside down, soaking a small area of the cloth.
He leaned forward, his expression focused as he poured the whiskey over your thigh, the liquid stinging the wound. The sharp burn made you gasp, and before you knew it, your hand instinctively gripped his arm, fingers curling around the firm muscle of his bicep.
“I know, I know,” he cooed softly, the sound of his voice low and reassuring. “You’re alright, girl.”
He wrapped the bandana around your thigh with careful precision, his touch both firm and gentle, the cloth tight enough to keep the wound clean but not too tight.
“Good as new,” he muttered with satisfaction, pulling back just enough to admire his work.
His elbow rested against the log, his posture relaxed yet still attentive as he leaned into it. His eyes drifted over your body for a moment, lingering just a fraction too long on your chest before he lifted his gaze to meet yours, his expression unreadable but the air between you thick with something unspoken.
Your fingers reached out, brushing against the rough stubble on Arthur’s jaw. The texture was coarse beneath your touch, and yet, the warmth of his skin sent a shiver through you. You scratched lightly, a tentative gesture that had him leaning into your hand, his movements slow and deliberate as he tilted his head into your caress.
His breath mingled with yours, warm and steady, and you could see the way his eyelids lowered, his gaze dark and intent, following your every move. There was a hesitance in him, a silent question he didn’t dare voice, but the way his hand came up to cup your cheek spoke volumes.
The roughness of his palm contrasted with the gentleness of his touch as he let his fingers trail back, cradling the nape of your neck. Then, with a subtle pull, he guided you closer, pressing his lips to yours in a kiss that was slow but all-consuming. The moment hung heavy with emotion, his breath hitching as he let himself get lost in it.
Without breaking the kiss, you shifted, sliding off the log and settling into his lap. His arms instinctively wrapped around you, steadying you, and the kiss deepened.
He didn't recoil from your touch, instead, he remained steadfast until he felt the unmistakable pressure of your groin against his crotch. A barely audible hiss escaped him at the intimate contact, his piercing blue eyes locked onto yours with intensity as they darkened to near-black from dilated pupils brimming with lust. "I don't think your sheriff daddy would take kindly to an outlaw gettin’ this close to his little girl,” he rasped out, his voice low and tinged with a menacing undercurrent of desire that left no doubt about the depraved thoughts swirling in his mind.
You tilt your head back, gazing up at him with eyes heavy-lidded and desire-filled, the world seems to fade away until there's only the two of you. With a sudden urgency, you claim his lips once more in a searing kiss, tongues tangling as if trying to merge into one.
He groans low in his throat, surrendering to the passion that consumes you both. His hands find their way beneath your shirt, fingers dancing over the soft curves of your stomach before cupping your breasts through the thin fabric of your bra.You can feel every ridge of his fingertips against your sensitive nipples as he palms and kneads the supple flesh.
The heat between you is almost unbearable as he presses closer. The evidence of his arousal throbs against your crotch, a thick bulge straining against his zipper that makes it impossible not to imagine what lies beneath.
With a ragged gasp, you break the kiss, a glistening string of saliva connecting your lips as you both struggle to catch your breath. His piercing blue eyes darkened with lust as he watches you fumble with his belt and zipper, eager to free the throbbing hardness straining against his jeans.
A low chuckle rumbles in his chest at your enthusiasm, hands gripping your waist possessively. As soon as the denim falls open, you dive in without hesitation, wrapping slender fingers around his thick length and giving it a tantalizing stroke. He flexes into your touch, hips bucking slightly as he watches through heavy-lidded eyes how delicate yet firm your grip is on him. The contrast between your small hand and his substantial cock is erotic in its own right. He places his large hand on top of yours, guiding your hand, showing you the rhythm he likes.
“That’s it, sweetheart,” he murmurs huskily against your ear, his breath hot and ragged. “Just like that.” The words are a sensual command, each syllable dripping with desire. As you follow the rhythm of his guidance, he grips your nape firmly with his free hand, tilting your head back to bring your mouth closer to his. His lips hover just out of reach for a moment before brushing tantalizingly against yours in a teasing caress that sends shivers down your spine. “Squeeze me a bit harder. I wanna feel that sweet hand milkin’ my cock” he mutters against your lips before delving into your mouth, tasting you all over again, your hand still working him.
His hands shift to unbuckle your jeans, unzipping them and pulling them down slightly, enough to reveal yourself to him and not undo the bandana he had used as a make-shift bandage. As his fingers graze the damp fabric of your panties, he can't help but smile at the evidence of your arousal. “You’re so wet. Is that for me?” he whispers, teasing you. He feels your eager nod, his chuckle is low and dark with promise. With a deliberate slowness, he pushes your panties to the side, exposing the delicate folds of your sex to his ravenous gaze. His finger traces along the slick, swollen flesh in long, teasing strokes that leave you panting softly against him. “Are you turned on by jackin’ me off?” he murmurs huskily into your ear, voice dripping with seduction as he teases at your entrance without fully penetrating.
Your continued nods and ragged breathing are all the permission he needs. It's as if he can read the desperate longing in every quiver of your body. Without further preamble, he sinks his thick middle finger deep inside you, pumping slowly to coat it in your slick. The sensation is overwhelming - pressure building steadily within you as he strokes and curls his finger. “You like that? Havin’ my finger inside you?”
With a deliberate slowness, he continues his sensual assault on your senses, his finger plunging deep into your quivering depths while thumb circling the sensitive nub of your clit. “Bet you can’t wait for my cock instead.” Each stroke is calculated to drive you closer to the edge, watching intently as you writhe and roll your hips against his hand in desperate pursuit of release.The desperation etched on your face only fuels his desire. His gaze never leaves yours, drinking in the sight of you lost in lustful abandon as he teases out moans and gasps with each expert touch.
Noticing how the added stimulation makes your legs tremble and twitch, he increases the pressure on your clit subtly, thumb rubbing in tight circles that send shockwaves through your core. The tempo remains slow and deliberate.
With a low, satisfied hum, he eases his glistening finger out of your clenching heat. His smirk widens at the sight of how much slick arousal coats his fingertip, evidence of just how turned on you are by his touch. Without hesitation, he brings the digit to his lips and licks it clean with a slow, languid swipe of his tongue. The taste is intoxicatingly yours, and he savors every drop before popping the finger from between his lips with a soft pop. He grips the waistbands of your panties tugging them down to meet your jeans.
His hands grip your hips with bruising force, pulling you flush against his body as he lines himself up with your dripping entrance. You can feel the thick head of his cock nudging insistently at your folds, teasing and prodding until you're whining in frustration from the pressure.
Arthur finally begins to sink you onto him, it's a slow, deliberate descent - each inch stretching and filling you more completely than the last. He groans low in his throat at the sensation of your tight heat enveloping him, relishing how your pussy grips him like a velvet vice as he burrows deeper. Your breath hitches and moans spill from lips parted in pleasure as he claims you inch by inch. The tension builds between you until finally, with a final thrust, he sheathes himself fully inside, bottoming out. He keeps you still, giving you a moment to adjust to his size, taking in your flushed face and heaving chest. “You’re doin’ so good”
You wrap your arms around his neck, rolling your hips slowly to accommodate his size, he murmurs words of encouragement. “That’s it, nice and slow.” he coaxes huskily, drinking in the sight of your face contorted with pleasure - each whimper and moan a symphony to his ears. However, when you deliberately pick up the pace to tantalizingly slow degrees, teasing him with every inch of movement his grip on your hips tightens reflexively. A low rumble escapes him as he chastises playfully, “I said nice and slow, not torture.” The words are laced with amusement rather than annoyance. But then he can't resist any longer. With a deep groan, he bucks up into you, thrusting hard enough to make the air whoosh from your lungs and send sparks dancing behind your eyelids.
“Good girl.” Arthur coos, his voice a low rumble of approval as he caresses your face with tender hands. His thumb traces the curve of your bottom lip, watching intently as his name tumbles from your lips in breathless pleas for more. You lean into him, resting subtle kisses on the crook of his neck and shoulder, using his large frame to stifle your moans, he takes control once again. “Takin’ me so well” he grunts out words with each thrust, punctuated by the slick slide of flesh against flesh. “You feel so good. So tight.”
Your movements quicken, your hips meeting his in a desperate rhythm. The air around you is thick with the sounds of your union—the slick, urgent slap of skin against skin, mingled with your breathless moans and the distant, rhythmic chirping of the surrounding wildlife. His grip on your hips tightened, the strength of it almost bruising as he began guiding you, lifting and lowering you onto him with a growing urgency. His thrusts grew erratic, each one driving deeper as he met your movements with his own.
A wicked smile tugged at his lips, his eyes fixed on you, dark and filled with satisfaction. He drank in every sound you made, every shiver of your body, relishing the way he was unraveling you. The pride in his expression was unmistakable, a silent acknowledgment of the pleasure coursing through you. His thrusts were firm and unrelenting, yet carried a careful restraint, ensuring he didn’t push beyond your comfort. Each movement was driven by his desire, but beneath the intensity was a tenderness that kept him attuned to you, his focus split between chasing his own pleasure and ensuring yours.
You writhe against him, back arching and nails digging into the fabric of his vest, he knows you're teetering on the brink of release. Your moans grow louder, more desperate as your thighs begin to tremble uncontrollably - a telltale sign that your climax is imminent. Without hesitation, he reaches down to find your clit with skilled fingers, rubbing in tight circles that send jolts of pleasure surging through your body. Occasionally, he pinches the sensitive nub just hard enough to elicit long, guttural moans from your parted lips. "That's it," he whispers huskily against your ear, "cum for me."
The words are an erotic command that seems to push you over the edge. Your entire being tenses as the first waves of orgasm crash over you, your arousal coating him, dripping onto and staining his jeans. “Arthur, Arthur!” You scream out his name, your nails digging deeper into his vest, leaving divots against the leather. “Good girl” He murmurs softly, your walls clenched tightly around him at the praise, drawing him in with a pressure that sent a shudder through his body. A low hiss escaped his lips at the sensation, his own thrusts become sloppy and brutal in his rhythm now, driven by a desperate need for release. "I'm close," he grunts through clenched teeth, his breath hot against your neck, his moans growing more vocal and urgent with each passing second. His head lolls back, eyes squeezed shut as he chases that elusive peak.
With one final powerful pull on your hips, he buries himself to the hilt inside you and stills. Hot waves of seed pulse out from him in thick spurts, filling you completely as he empties himself within your welcoming heat. The sensation is overwhelming - every twitch and throb sending aftershocks rippling through both bodies.
He reached up, his calloused thumb brushing across your forehead to wipe away the beads of sweat that clung to your skin. With the same tenderness, his fingers gently pushed back the strands of hair sticking to your damp face, tucking them behind your ear.
“You were so good,” he murmured, his voice low and filled with quiet adoration. His hand moved to your back, his palm warm and firm as he rubbed slow, soothing circles, offering comfort and reassurance with every stroke. “You were alright, I guess,” you teased, your voice light but tinged with breathlessness, your face flushed with color.
Arthur’s laugh rumbled deep in his chest, a sound that was equal parts amusement and satisfaction. “Is that so?” he drawled, a mischievous glint in his eyes. Before you could respond, he shifted beneath you, bucking up just enough to make you gasp and squirm against him. His grin widened at your reaction, his expression filled with playful arrogance. “Reckon I can do better next time, then.”
Arthur gently eased you off of him, his hands careful and steady as he helped tug your panties and jeans back into place. His touch was tender, almost reverent, as though he didn’t want to rush the moment. Once you were dressed, he placed his hands firmly on your waist, lifting you effortlessly to your feet, his eyes scanning you briefly for any sign of discomfort before guiding you toward your horse.
With the same ease, he helped you up into the saddle, making sure you were settled before hoisting himself up in front of you. He took hold of the reins, and you instinctively leaned forward, wrapping your arms around his waist for balance.
“You gettin’ comfortable?” he teased, a low chuckle escaping him as he felt you nestle against his back. His tone was light, but there was an unmistakable warmth in it, the kind that made you feel like this was exactly where you were meant to be.
He let out a sharp whistle, the sound cutting through the air. His horse trotted into view, ears flicking as it obediently fell into step beside Yours while Arthur was riding.
Reaching out, he guided it with a steady hand, ensuring it stayed close and kept the still unconscious bounty was secure, the horse began its steady pace back toward Valentine. With one of his hands loosely on your horse’s reins and the other keeping his horse in line.
The rhythmic clopping of hooves on the trail filled the air as the two of you rode on, the quiet companionship between you feeling both natural and unspoken.
Arthur dismounted your horse with ease, landing lightly on his feet before turning to you. Without hesitation, he reached up, his strong hands gently grasping your waist as he lifted you off the saddle and set you down. His movements were careful, almost protective, as though mindful of your injured leg.
He took the reins of your horse, hitching it securely alongside his own before turning his attention back to you. “You’re okay, huh? Your leg feels fine?” he asked, his tone steady but laced with concern.
You nodded, offering him a small smile. “I’m fine, thank you. I’m tough!”
He reached out, his large hand ruffling through your hair in a gesture that was both teasing and affectionate. “That’s my girl,” he murmured, his voice soft, almost proud as he regarded you.
The warmth of his words made your cheeks flush, and you let out a small, flustered laugh, gently pushing his hand away in a halfhearted protest. Despite yourself, the gesture only made you feel closer to him.
"One sec," he muttered, his tone casual as he turned away. Arthur walked to his horse, hauling the unconscious bounty off with practiced ease and slinging the man over his shoulder.
Without another word, he made his way to the sheriff’s office, the door creaking open as he stepped inside. Moments later, he emerged, his hands free and his stride relaxed as he returned to you. His expression was calm, the job done, and his focus once again entirely on you.
“Had to show off?” you tease, a playful smirk tugging at your lips.
“I didn’t tell you to stare,” he shot back with a laugh, his deep voice carrying a warmth that made your chest tighten.
He turned, heading back to his horse with his usual unhurried confidence. With a practiced motion, he swung himself onto the saddle, his movements smooth and effortless. Guiding his horse, he trotted it closer to you, the smile on his face as teasing as his tone.
“I’ll see you around, little lady,” he drawled, tipping his head slightly.
“You know where to find me,” you replied, your voice steady, though your heart raced.
Arthur leaned down, his large hand brushing gently through your hair once more, petting you, the touch brief but leaving behind an unmistakable warmth. Clicking his tongue, he urged his horse forward, its hooves picking up speed as he rode off into the distance.
You stood there, watching him disappear down the trail, the sound of his horse fading into the quiet. Your fingers drifted to his bandana, still snugly tied around your thigh, the fabric a lingering reminder of his touch. You couldn’t help but miss him already.
The ache of his absence settling over you like a quiet longing.