Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2025-05-11
Updated:
2025-05-28
Words:
31,373
Chapters:
9/?
Comments:
72
Kudos:
152
Bookmarks:
18
Hits:
2,324

even in arcadia [pilot edition]

Summary:

Odysseus is an athlete who uses his loud mouth to hide his baggage. Penelope is a musician whose dreams supersede her family's expectations. How it took him so long to notice her in such a small town is beyond him, but now that he has, she's all he can think about.

It's too bad his past experiences have made damn sure nothing will ever come of it...right?

Or, the "high school au" trope meets a (largely) texting fic meets the canon events of EPIC

NOTE: [edition one] is considered a rough draft and will no longer have updates pending

Notes:

**EDIT 08.10.2025** hi all, I'm so sorry for how long it's been since I've touched a chapter of this fic. I'm working on making a more long-form/one-chaptered fic with the same premise and title so that there's less pressure on me to complete a whole novel's worth of words lol. thanku all for being so patient and I'm so sorry to report that there will be no further updates for this as far as I can tell. this story is my baby and I love her but she's "flown the coop" (the coop being my brain). I hope you all enjoy what content I do have here!!

hey guys!

it's been a large minute since I tried to tackle writing a fic longer than maybe a thousand or so words, so this is both exciting and like suuuuuper daunting for me lol. but the Muse (brain worms) have sung to me nonstop about odysseus and penelope, which means now I have to write about them.

the title from this fic is based off of the album "even in arcadia," by sleep token. in fact, the title track reminded me SO much of odysseus' journey that I'm like 99% sure he ghostwrote it lmao. I hope this fic conveys both the themes of the album as well as the themes of EPIC.

here's an important disclaimer: a LOT of the experiences I'm writing about are not personal to me nor have I ever myself been through them. which means that while I'm hoping to stay true to the EPIC canon (as much as I can in a modern, technological context), I'm also trying not to project my perspective onto things that require more sensitivity. namely with the whole calypso fiasco because yes it does come into play with this work and does massively affect ody as the story progresses. I'm also just not an expert in greek mythology outside of the numerous wikipedia pages I've scoured. tbh though if something or someone seems out of place or out of character, it's likely due to this being done in a present-day(ish) setting instead of in an ancient setting.

about comments: comments will be moderated, but rest assured I do accept most of them! I just try to save it for when I can read them and respond properly. please don't ask me about updates or anything like that, it creates a lot of pressure for me. also if you have a personal gripe that isn't related to something I specifically have done wrong in the writing, save it for a later date :]

warnings and precautions will be at the beginning of each chapter. TAGS WILL CHANGE AS IT GOES ALONG. not every tag has been added even as I'm publishing this, so heed what's up so far and be mindful of the archive warnings I've attached. above all else please use discretion and be safe while you read.

huge huge HUGE shout-out to sillykeychains for the gorgeous fic that is operation penelope. I'm having so much fun reading it and I'm in LOVE with the way they write odypen's dynamic.

with all that housekeeping out of the way, hope you guys enjoy :]

Chapter 1: there's a fire at the gates

Summary:

the new year kicks into full swing

Notes:

chapter warnings: underage drinking, ableism, odysseus ringing the damn hubris bell again and again (and again and a g a i n--)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

 

 

 

The Boyz
Group Message
12/31/2016

5:07 P.M.

 

Diabetes: hey ody are u coming to the nye party
Diabetes: ody
Diabetes: odyyyyyy
Diabetes: ODYYYYYYYYYYYY

Eggman: calm your tits dio
Eggman: he's probably just at the boxinh ring again

Diabetes: nah bro boxing ring is fridays

Eggman: not you having his schedule memorized
Eggman: that's kinda gay
Eggman: do i bother reminding you of the eighth grade fiasco

T-Bag: Woahhh fiascos a big word for you eggy

Eggman: >:(

Diabetes: [Replying to Eggman]: IT WAS ONE TIME
Diabetes: IN A DREAM

Eggman: sure sure

T-Bag: Im not going
T-Bag: Teucer and I are doing shots at his place

Eggman: oooh say hi to teucer
Eggman: miss that man

Garfield: gay

Diabetes: ODYYYYY
Diabetes: WHERE HAVE U BEEN

Garfield: dio my brother in christ
Garfield: I was in the mf shower
Garfield: my dumbass woke up so late dude

T-Bag: By late do you mean 6 am

Diabetes: OHHHHHHHHH
Diabetes: GET WRECKED MOTHAFUCKA

Garfield: lmaoooo
Garfield: idk if I can go tbh
Garfield: today sucked and I'm tired as hell
Garfield: and my mom's hounding me about shit

Eggman: aw rats sorry ody :((

Diabetes: ya bro sorry for pestering

Garfield: it's fine I'll just like
Garfield: go to athena's or smth
Read by all 5:39 P.M.

 

 

 

Sissy
Messages
12/31/2016

6:08 P.M.

 

Sissy: mom's rlly not happy with u
Sissy: doesn't like the idea of u getting plastered

Big Brother: it's the new year
Big Brother: literally everyone is getting plastered
Big Brother: you saw mom went to cosmo's right

Sissy: ugh whatever
Sissy: just don't do anything stupid pls
Sissy: and be back b4 she's up tomorrow
Sissy: i'd be so embarrassed for u if u got lectured about that

Big Brother: fine
Big Brother: all I'm saying is she's the last person who can lecture me about being drunk on new year's eve
Big Brother: and she says the same things every year about it

Sissy: okay okay damn
Sissy: maybe i also just want u to be safe
Sissy: bitch

Big Brother: aw are you getting sappy on me
Big Brother: jerk

Sissy: sfkjdkjg I KNEW U KNEW THE REFERENCE
Sissy: but srsly be safe and have fun
Sissy: and don't be pissy at either of us tomorrow morning

Big Brother: idk if I'm even going tho

Sissy: oh
Sissy: wait i thought the juniors n seniors were throwing a huge party

Big Brother: oh they are
Big Brother: jury's still out on if I'll be there
Big Brother: I just needed a break so I'm going to athena's

Sissy: omg pls say hi to her bird for me

Big Brother: lmao I'll do my best
Read 6:16 P.M.

 

 

 

Bitchass
Messages

12/31/2016

7:54 P.M.

 

Fuckface: I changed my mind

Bitchass: YAYYYYY
Bitchass: cannot wait to seeee yiuuuuuuuuuuuu

Fuckface: omfg dude
Fuckface: are you already plastered ??

Bitchass: nooooooooo judt come ober

Fuckface: sure dio sure
Delivered 8:01 P.M.

 

 

 

Sissy
Messages
12/31/2016

11:28 P.M.

 

Sissy: happy new year
Sissy: i know it's not actually here yet but
Sissy: ur prolly not gonna be home by midnight so
Sissy: happy new year
Read 12:43 A.M.

 

 

 

Po
Messages
01/01/2017

10:04 A.M.

 

Ody: happy new year!

Po: hapoy new yesr ody :))
Po: fucj i still cabt type

Ody: it's ok man
Ody: you know I don't mind
Ody: just glad to catch you on a day you can text back yk

Po: PT is kicjing me in the ass
Po: at leadt the nww year is like
Po: stsrtinh over
Po: right?

Ody: you're so right !!
Ody: this year's gonna be your year dude
Po liked your message!
Read 10:13 A.M.

 

 

 

Bitchass
Messages
01/01/2017

1:20 P.M.

 

Bitchass: did u ever get that girls number by the way

Fuckface: ???
Fuckface: what girl ??

Bitchass: DONT PLAY WITH ME RN
Bitchass: DO U ACTUALLY NOT REMEMBER
Bitchass: YALL WERE TALKING ALL DAMN NIGHT

Fuckface: wait
Fuckface: it's coming back to me
Fuckface: oh fuck dude
Fuckface: fuckkkkkk she was so pretty

Bitchass: please tell me u got her number

Fuckface: ...

Bitchass: odysseus laertides
Bitchass: i swear to god bro

Fuckface: I mean how do you expect me to remember tho ??
Fuckface: you were JUST helping me through the worst hangover of my life like
Fuckface: two hours ago

Bitchass: FUCK
Bitchass: this couldve been so good but u fumbled

Fuckface: man fuck off all we did was talk
Fuckface: I don't even remember what she looks like so who cares yk

Bitchass: [Replying to Fuckface]: "i dont even remember what she looks like" U FUCKIN LIARRRR
Bitchass: ur just embarrassed

Fuckface: your mom's just embarrassed

Bitchass: be so serious with me ody

Fuckface: no but actually I cannot remember her face
Fuckface: I just know it had to be one of the prettiest mf faces

Bitchass: excuses excuses
Bitchass: 
fuck dude u looked so smiley w her too
Bitchass: if i were more sober id have recorded it
Bitchass: never seen u so in ur element like that

Fuckface: maybe I'll just see her at next year's nye party
Fuckface: she's someone from achaea right

Bitchass: not sure lol
Bitchass: there were a couple people from out of town
Bitchass: i think

Fuckface: well
Fuckface: it is what it is
Fuckface: maybe we can find her at school somehow
Fuckface: fuck who's someone we could ask who knows everybody tho

Bitchass: i dont even know bro
Bitchass: maybe achilles
Bitchass: but id rather eat my own feet then ask him for help
Bitchass: snobby fuck

Fuckface: *than

Bitchass: be nice to me

Fuckface: you sound like ctimene right now
Fuckface: but you're right
Fuckface: I'd also rather not ask achilles

Bitchass: hed be so
Bitchass: whats the word

Fuckface: indelicate?

Bitchass: ugh u genius man
Bitchass: yeah hed be sooooooo indelicate about it

Fuckface: if only po still went to our school
Fuckface:
he would know who it is right off the bat
Fuckface: fucker's got the memory of a steel trap

Bitchass: yeah
Bitchass: hows he doin

Fuckface: wdym

Bitchass: like u know
Bitchass: u text him so
Bitchass: maybe im just curious

Fuckface: yk you can text him yourself right
Fuckface: ?

Bitchass: oh yeah
Bitchass: ur so right
Bitchass: i guess im just nervous about it though

Fuckface: ...

Bitchass: what

Fuckface: not this fucking bs again
Fuckface: you and your same reasons I stg
Fuckface: dio man
Fuckface: ily no homo
Fuckface: but have you seriously still not reached out to him ??

Bitchass: he can barely hold a spoon ody
Bitchass: he didnt even recognize me when we visited right after
Bitchass: it was awkward as hell

Fuckface: imagine how he feels
Fuckface: wow
Fuckface: that actually sucks of you
Fuckface: yk what you can ask achilles for all I care

Bitchass: bro dont act like u message him 24/7 or something
Bitchass: u were just saying the other day how awful u felt every time u remembered why he can barely keep up a conversation

Fuckface: that's not the same and you fucking know it too
Fuckface: 
don't talk to me until you've messaged him a happy goddamn new year

Bitchass: ody come on
Bitchass: odysseus
Bitchass: [Message deleted]
Read 2:19 P.M.

 

 

 

Eurylochus
Messages
01/01/2017

6:32 P.M.

 

Odysseus: happy new year
Message could not be sent.

 

 

 

Patroclus
Messages
01/02/2017

9:36 A.M.

 

Patroclus: Hey we have practice today right?

Odysseus: next week
Odysseus: 3:30 to 4:30

Patroclus: Sweet! I'll tell Achilles
Patroclus: Thanks cap'n :}

Odysseus: pat no offense
Odysseus: but you already knew that
Odysseus: your schedule is color coded so what's up

Patroclus: Why aren't you talking to Dio?

Odysseus: who says I'm not talking to dio ??

Patroclus: I say
Patroclus: He never looks this sad and mopey unless you two are fighting
Patroclus: Obviously you don't have to answer if you don't want

Odysseus: pat I really appreciate you
Odysseus: but please don't try to come in the middle of this
Odysseus: it'll only make things weirder for the rest of the guys
Odysseus: and I really don't wanna do that

Patroclus: Okay
Patroclus: If you ever want to talk just let me know :}
Read 9:42 A.M.

 

 

 

Athena
Messages
01/02/2017

4:13 P.M.

 

Athena: Call me when you get the chance.

Odysseus: whatever you have to say it's fine
Odysseus: I was being stubborn

Athena: So was I.
Athena: There's no need for doing this in text messages.
Athena: Call me.
Read 5:08 P.M.

 

 

 

Sissy
Messages
01/02/2017

7:39 P.M.

 

Sissy: are u gonna eat
Sissy: mom made a plate for u

Big Brother: I'll be down in a sec
Big Brother: I'm on the phone
Big Brother: not a call I can miss

Sissy: okay
Read 7:40 P.M.

 

 

 

Bitchass
Messages
01/03/2017

1:02 A.M.

 

Bitchass: u up

Fuckface: what do you want

Bitchass: u were right ody
Bitchass: i was being an idiot

Fuckface: and

Bitchass: i messaged him
Bitchass: he was real happy to hear from me

Fuckface: good
Fuckface: I'm sleeping now
Fuckface: night loser

Bitchass: goodnight bitch
Read 7:38 A.M.

 

 

 

Poseidon ([email protected]) | 01/03/2017 at 12:29 P.M.
To: Me +10 other recipients
CC:
Subject: Swim Season

Good afternoon gentlemen.

Achaea High's swimming season is almost upon us. Our schedule will remain the same as it did last year, with practices on Mondays through Thursdays from 3:30 to 4:30. Our monthly meetings with neighboring districts will be the last Friday of each month, with information about regionals to follow. A full schedule is being made and will be sent out in due time (many thanks again to Patroclus for lending us his spreadsheets).

An email will be sent school wide for anyone who wishes to step up and try out. Returning members will not need to do a full examination, but will be required to participate in a water safety test.

Happy new year. Stay ruthless and rested,

Coach

 

 

 

Poseidon ([email protected]) | 01/03/2017 at 1:04 P.M.
To: Me
CC:
Subject: 
Captain's Requirements

Good afternoon Odysseus.

As a reminder, captains will need to maintain a grade of B or higher in each class and extracurricular to keep their position. I noticed your grades have been drifting. It would be a shame if I had to delegate this responsibility to someone else. Consider reviewing this with your advisor and making any necessary changes. Thank you.

Stay ruthless and rested,

Coach

 

 

 

The Boyz
Group Message

01/03/2017

4:47 P.M.

 

Garfield: hypothetically speaking

Diabetes: oh god

Garfield: could I get away with murdering our swim coach
Garfield: or at least maiming him

Eggman: is he still on yoir ass about grades

Garfield: yeah man I got a wholeass email about it

Diabetes: what the fresh hell
Diabetes: he has to know ur like
Diabetes: one of the best students here right

Garfield: I guess not ??
Garfield: idk what the fuck he's worried about my grades are fine

Diabetes: then whats he so salty about

T-Bag: Maybe hes concerned about last year
T-Bag: (Not to beat a dead horse tho)

Eggman: nooo bc he would still have issues
Eggman: he's the type of guy to remember likr everything for no reason

Garfield: cantankerous asshat

Diabetes: what the fuck is cantankerous

Garfield: tell me you did not just ask me that
Garfield: skill issue dude

Eggman: skill issue

T-Bag: Skill issue

Diabetes: be so nice to me oh my god
Read by all 4:59 P.M.

 

 

 

Sissy
Messages
01/04/2017

6:39 A.M.

 

Sissy: mom says ur driving me to school

Big Brother: you're right down the hall from me
Big Brother: no knock on my door ??
Big Brother: no good morning ??

Sissy: good morning
Sissy: mom says ur driving me to school

Big Brother: cannot fucking wait until you have your license
Read 6:42 A.M.

 

 

 

Bitchass
Messages
01/04/2017

2:43 P.M.

 

Fuckface: dio
Fuckface: dio I found her

Bitchass: found who

Fuckface: THE girl
Fuckface: the literal girl of my dreams
Fuckface: I'm so convinced dude

Bitchass: u sure the whole new year of it all isnt getting to u ody
Bitchass: cause u were wasted
Bitchass: how do u even know its her
Bitchass: and what if shes like totally different outside of that party

Fuckface: trust me
Fuckface: it's definitely her
Fuckface: also mf weren't you literally just saying I should've gotten her number

Bitchass: yeah but like its been a few days now
Bitchass:
[Replying to Fuckface]: give me a name or im not buying it

Fuckface: are you serious

Bitchass: mf yes
Bitchass: now
Bitchass: the name

Fuckface: I don't know her name
Fuckface: but she's in chem with ajax t and I
Fuckface: oh and she brings her knitting with her to home economics
Fuckface: I don't know how the fuck I didn't know who she was before
Fuckface: how did it take a wholeass party ??

Bitchass: okay casanova hold ur horses

Fuckface: I'm not saying I'm going for it

Bitchass: then why are u sooooo excited about it wink wink nudge nudge

Fuckface: maybe she and I will get to talk again
Fuckface: then we can be friends or smth
Fuckface: besides she's so out of my league I can already tell

Bitchass: quit that
Bitchass: ur a total catch bro

Fuckface: ily bro
Fuckface: no homo

Bitchass: yeah yeah love u too ody
Read 3:09 P.M.

 

 

 


 

 

 

Call Transcript: Athena & Odysseus
01/02/2017
Duration: 00:01:42

A: Hey, kid.

O: Hey.

A: Listen, I'm sorry for what I said--

O: Don't. Just...it's fine, I was just being stupid.

A: You were being kind, Odysseus. There's a difference.

O: Then why'd you say what you said?

A: Well, if you'll let me finish...[sigh] I said what I said because...

[...]

O: Yes?

A: I just don't want you getting yourself hurt.

O: You can't prevent that!

[...]

O: I'm sorry 'thena, but you just can't, okay? There's no changing what happened to him, and there's no changing how it feels for me. It's not your job to make it any...any more or less of anything.

A: No, no. You're right. Just...be careful. That's all I'm asking.

O: I am. I will.

A: Good.

O: Yep.

A: Right then...how're you holding up?

O: Fine.

[...]

O: Are we still boxing on Friday?

A: I could pencil you in.

O: Okay.

[...]

O: I gotta go, now. Mom made dinner.

A: Okay. Goodnight.

O: Bye.

 

 

 

Notes:

who's who in these messages:

diabetes = diomedes
eggman = agamemnon
t-bag = ajax the great
garfield = odysseus

sissy = ctimene
big brother = odysseus

bitchass = diomedes
fuckface = odysseus

hopefully context clues help with some of the names and such but just in case!! here's a little guide to help :]