firstborn_unicorn
Fandoms
- Slender Man Mythos (1)
- Creepypasta - Fandom (1)
- Marble Hornets (1)
Recent works
-
The Strangest Strangers by firstborn_unicorn
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, Slender Man Mythos
14 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
The man was still for a while, watching Toby as if the boy were a wounded animal. This guy didn’t seem too dangerous, he was bigger than Toby, sure, but Toby was a fast runner. The ugly side burns also didn’t necessarily scream “danger” all that much, either.
The boy narrowed his eyes at the man, his hand tightening around a hatchet, and eyebrows furrowing as he looked down at it. Why does he have this, and is this blood that it’s covered in? There was another one on the ground next to him too. He didn’t even realize he was carrying these. The man’s gaze followed Toby’s, and quickly raised his hands in mock surrender, stepping out from behind the tree.
“What the hell happened to you, kid?”
--
Or, my own take on how Toby met Tim and Brian.
Recent series
-
- Words:
- 0
- Works:
- 0
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Burnt out and exhausted with city life, Etho packs up and moves to the old abandoned farm his parents owned before he was born. It's sat empty for thirty years and it's not in a good state, but he's determined to make the most of it.
The town is full of good people, and he quickly finds friendship in abundance. Amongst them all though, one stands out. Bdubs is kind and funny and exceptionally talented at a number of things. He's handsome too, and Etho can't help but crush on him, just a little bit.
They get along fantastically right from day one, but Etho keeps his feelings to himself. It's just a crush, it'll go away. And besides, it's not like Bdubs would ever like him back... Right?
-
Tags
Summary
Toby gets hit in the face and now it’s Brian and Tim’s problem too.
-
The Sun So Hot I Froze To Death by the_names_of_those_who_love_the_lord
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
05 Jan 2016
Tags
Summary
Toby Rogers lived next to the forest where children sometimes died. His father wouldn't look at him anymore. Shapes moved in his walls at night. A crazy hobo with a Southern lilt in his voice and half a face had taken a shine to him.
Everything was fine.
Series
-
fell in love with the thought of you (now I’m choked up, face down, burnt out) by corbluvs2read
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
21 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
[...] The sound of her footsteps continue for a moment after the back door opens, but Jeff doesn't think much of it.
Thirteen seconds later, Toby (he'd heard his name in the hallway the day after "the incident" through hushed whispers of did you hear that Toby broke Jeff's nose on his first day?) comes barrelling into the room, and Jeff wonders if he should've.
There's a new proxy. Jeff's kind of obsessed with him, even though they've barely spoken, and have never once had a pleasant conversation. He deals with it accordingly.
-
Tags
Summary
What if the Creepypasta characters were real-life killers idolized the same way horror movie slashers were? Kids dressing up as Ghostface or Pennywise? More like kids decorated as Jeff the Killer or Slenderman! You chose to dress as your favorite mass murderer, Ticci Toby- and, oh, how he couldn’t get enough of it. He had never seen someone look so good in his goggles.